Categories: Politics

Resistance to the change of the tax system

There must be an end to unpleasant surprises at the tax bill and thus combating tax debts and losses.

Preventing tax debts and tax losses, that is the goal of SP National Councilor Emmanuel Amoos (42). In an initiative he therefore advocates a voluntary direct deduction of taxes from wages.

In the future, income taxes will have to be paid directly to the responsible tax office – unless the employees expressly request otherwise. As is already the case with the withholding tax for foreign employees. If you then claim deductions on your tax return, you will receive a refund.

administrative overhead

Amoos managed to win over 85 parliamentarians in advance. But now the setback: the responsible committee for economics and taxation of the National Council (WAK-N) rejects the initiative.

The introduction of a voluntary wage deduction would lead to additional administrative work for the company and for the administration, according to a press release about the decision. At the same time, a tax return would still be required for taxpayers.

Volunteering does not solve the problem

And further: The biggest problem of people with debts is their handling of money. Voluntariness would therefore not solve the problem, especially since voluntary prepayments are already possible today.

“It is not certain whether the tax losses would actually decrease after the change,” says Commission President Leo Müller (centre). Because: in the canton of St. Gallen, for example, there are currently more tax shortfalls in the withholding tax for foreign employees than in the income tax for residents. The withholding tax is paid directly by the employer.

Withholding tax is not a perfect example

In fact, the depreciation rate in the canton of St. Gallen is higher for withholding taxes at 0.7 percent (2021) than for income and wealth taxes. There it is less than 0.5 percent (2021).

If taxes are deducted directly from wages, there is no guarantee that the money will actually be transferred to the tax authorities, explains Peter Sager, head of the cantonal tax office in St. Gallen. There are always bankruptcies.

“A voluntary deduction makes no sense”

“A voluntary deduction makes no sense because those taxpayers who are not in control of their finances would reject the tax deduction,” Sager says of the proposed change. In addition, the withholding only affects income tax on wages, but not other income and property tax.

However, the 2016 report, on which Amoos’ proposal is based, came to a very different conclusion: not only tax debts, but even the entire private debt would be reduced.

Avoid nasty surprises

Somehow, “For me, the tax losses are less of a compelling argument than helping those who are struggling with the current system,” says St. Gallen National Councilor Franziska Ryser (31, Greens). She co-signed the initiative and is also a member of the Economic Commission.

You can of course pay earlier today. “But especially for younger people, for example in the first year after apprenticeship, the bill at the end of the year can be a nasty surprise,” says Ryser.

The decision in the Economics Committee was taken by 15 to 10 votes. It cannot therefore be ruled out that the proponents of a systemic change will still prevail in the National Council, which will decide next. However, it is not likely.

Thomas Muller
Source:Blick

Share
Published by
Livingstone

Recent Posts

Terror suspect Chechen ‘hanged himself’ in Russian custody Egyptian President al-Sisi has been sworn in for a third term

On the same day of the terrorist attack on the Krokus City Hall in Moscow,…

1 year ago

Locals demand tourist tax for Tenerife: “Like a cancer consuming the island”

class="sc-cffd1e67-0 iQNQmc">1/4Residents of Tenerife have had enough of noisy and dirty tourists.It's too loud, the…

1 year ago

Agreement reached: this is how much Tuchel will receive for his departure from Bayern

class="sc-cffd1e67-0 iQNQmc">1/7Packing his things in Munich in the summer: Thomas Tuchel.After just over a year,…

1 year ago

Worst earthquake in 25 years in Taiwan +++ Number of deaths increased Is Russia running out of tanks? Now ‘Chinese coffins’ are used

At least seven people have been killed and 57 injured in severe earthquakes in the…

1 year ago

Now the moon should also have its own time (and its own clocks). These 11 photos and videos show just how intense the Taiwan earthquake was

The American space agency NASA would establish a uniform lunar time on behalf of the…

1 year ago

This is how the Swiss experienced the earthquake in Taiwan: “I saw a crack in the wall”

class="sc-cffd1e67-0 iQNQmc">1/8Bode Obwegeser was surprised by the earthquake while he was sleeping. “It was a…

1 year ago